For class, I wrote a letter about Disney princess body portrayals. I am passionate about this issue because I have struggled with body image at various points in my life. I am not blaming Disney for that, but I do think the media has played a HUGE role in making me feel like my body is not good enough. Here is the letter I wrote:
Dear Robert A. Iger,
I
would like to offer some feedback concerning portrayals of females in Disney
films. I have been impressed by movies like as Brave and Frozen that feature
girls who are not stereotyped as the damsel in distress with
love-at-first-sight syndrome. Specifically in Brave, I appreciate that Merida
is depicted with a realistic waistline and body type. She is also spunky and
different, with great character development throughout the movie. The first
time I watched Frozen, I was so excited about Disney princesses whose sole
purpose was not to win the prince. The film was about love between sisters and
I felt like I could really relate because I have a close bond with my sister. Thank
you for stepping outside the box and introducing more complex and deep
characters and plots. These are the kinds of movies that I really enjoy and
that I want my future children to enjoy.
While
there are many other things I truly appreciate about Disney films, such as the
prosocial behavior of characters, I would like to bring some criticisms to your
attention. I am currently enrolled in a university class that explores the
effects of media on human development and I have analyzed some components of
your Disney princess movies and advertising through that lens. Growing up, I
idolized Disney princesses and wanted to be just like Ariel or Belle. However,
as I have come to view the princesses more critically, I am disappointed. Most
Disney princesses have extremely unrealistic and impossible body proportions
that can really skew girls’ perceptions of body image and expectations. What is
stopping Disney from widening waistlines to a normal proportion? I would like
these “role models,” that are so influential for young girls, to be normal body
sizes and types! Even in movies such as the new Cinderella, the use of a corset
to create a ridiculous, though not fake, “ideal” or standard, in my opinion,
undermines the good message of the movie. I think it is more detrimental to see
a real person achieving that sort of proportion than it is to see a cartoon
depiction. I am afraid women will feel inadequate because their normal waists
cannot look like Lily James’ corset-tightened waist on an empty stomach. The
diversity of ethnicities, social economic statuses, and roles of females have
all been great improvements, but the body types of these princess protagonists
continue to be disproportionate, misrepresentative and irresponsible portrayals
of “normal” bodies. I would like to see that change made in future films.
Additionally,
I am frustrated that the advertising and merchandise of more realistic
characters are changed and sexualized. Taking Merida as an example again, her
body type in the movie is more normal, but her picture on certain products or
merchandise is grossly skewed to the typical Disney princess unfeasible
waistline. She is also made to look like an adult, with make-up and a more revealing
dress. I think this is sending the wrong message to young children and teens. I
think you are doing a better job with producing some more realistic, relatable
characters, but the body type depictions must be improved as well. Children
look up to and idolize these characters and giving impossible standards may
possibly lead to negative outcomes and unhealthy self-images for children starting
at a young age. Please consider making changes in your future productions.
In
conclusion, I believe you are producing great films and improving by creating
more complex female protagonists, but there is a real need to examine the
messages you are sending by creating impossible, unrealistic body types for
these characters. Thank you for making family-friendly films with good values
and I hope you will continue to do so while making improvements to benefit the
young viewers you target.
Sincerely,
Chelsea Borup
|
Like what is this?! Disney Princess 10 year Reunion??? |
|
What's so hard about these minor changes? |